We hope that the ‘Entrance gateway structure’ bears no resemblance to the image shown in Plate 14. If a metal frame is to be used we suggest it should be discretely embedded in the exiting limestone wall at Bateman Quay. The Brewery site should blend seamlessly with the medieval city centre and not have ‘statement’ entrances. The LED lighting strip in the walkway at the entrance has no place in a medieval city. However there could be a distinctive paving at the entrance.
We have reservations about the 3 m route through the garden being used by cyclists. This route should primarily be for pedestrians and wheelchair users. Cyclists should be separated or required to dismount in the interests of safety and peaceful enjoyment by pedestrians who are being encouraged by the design to enjoy the planting, artworks and views. Cyclists will have access to the Brewery site through the proposed ‘Street’.
Planting: We welcome the retention and reinforcement of the river bank planting. The commitment to the use of mainly native species is also desirable. For plants favoured by pollinators throughout the seasons the National Biodiversity Centre are proposing to put a list on their website in Springtime see www.biodiversityireland.ie . It is unfortunate that the narrowness of the park precludes large stately trees but some tall trees could be included if the lower branches are removed as they grow. Fruit trees and herbs would be a valued addition for wildlife. Most planting would benefit from removal of the concrete slab. Consideration should be given to greening the CAS bridge with vertical climbers or attached plants, and to fitting bat boxes beneath the bridge under Bat Conservation Ireland guidance.
Paving Materials: It is proposed to use paving materials seen throughout Kilkenny City. We are concerned that this will include imported materials such as those used on the Parade. Use of some local fossil limestone paving would enhance the space.